Top Siding Repair Services in Appleton

- Overall impression: Strongly positive experiences with professionalism, responsiveness, and value.

- Responsiveness and scheduling: Quick responses, often next-day or on-time appointments, with prompt on-site visits.

- Communication: Clear, courteous updates throughout the process; staff explained options and avoided high-pressure sales; estimates and next steps were communicated effectively.

- Range of work: Performed a variety of projects including siding repairs, roof work (including metal roofs), chimney flashing, vent pipe covers, garage roof, and replacing/removing a covered patio structure.

- Quality and results: Repairs described as thorough and precise; many projects resulted in looks-and-function improvements, with some cases noted as “looks flawless” after completion.

- Problem-solving approach: Identified issues over the phone when possible; addressed on-site; often used a repair-first approach before considering replacement; willing to troubleshoot multiple times to find the right fix (including leak-related issues).

- Insurance assistance: Team helped explain and navigate insurance claim options.

- Pricing and value: Prices described as fair or excellent value; no aggressive upselling; customers felt they got good value for the work.

- Cleanliness and site care: Work areas were cleaned up and left tidy after projects.

- Professionalism and courtesy: Staff (including Jeff, Isaak, and Dan) praised for professionalism, attentiveness, and respect for customers’ homes.

- Repeat business and referrals: High likelihood of using the company again and recommending it to friends and family.

- Handling challenging jobs: Comfortable with old or complex systems and challenging roofs; customers felt confident in the team’s ability to manage difficult repairs.

- Balanced note: In one case, a leak persisted after an initial repair and required two troubleshooting visits, but ultimately resolution was achieved.

- Overall, customer experiences with Andra Contracting (Timothy Andra) are consistently positive across roofing, siding, and exterior repair projects, including work on homes and outbuildings.
- Key strengths cited: responsive communication and clear explanations; timely quotes and scheduling; honest pricing with few, if any, unexpected costs; and thorough, professional workmanship.
- Project delivery: many customers report completing work on or ahead of schedule, with careful attention to detail and high-quality results (e.g., roof replacements and shedding or upgrading materials).
- Site and cleanup: frequent notes of meticulous clean-up, removal of nails, and respectful treatment of property; many customers say the site looked as if no work had been performed after completion.
- Trust and professionalism: owners and crews are described as courteous, honest, reliable, and customer-focused; many buyers mention direct interaction with the owner and a willingness to accommodate changes or add-ons without inflating costs.
- Scope of work: reviews cover roof replacements (including replacing old metal roofs with shingles or steel), roof repairs on outbuildings, siding projects, and even install/upgrade elements like skylights and sheds.
- Value and repeat business: multiple comments indicate good value and willingness to hire again for future projects; several customers would recommend or already recommended Andra Contracting to others.
- Notable positives: timely responses, consistent updates (often via photos/texts), and a reputation for keeping promises and delivering on commitments.

Customer feedback on Advantage Exteriors shows generally positive experiences across exterior work, including roofing, gutters, soffit, fascia, and planned siding projects. Practical outcomes repeatedly cited include rapid completion (often a single day for roof work), thorough on-site cleanup with few nails or debris left behind, and noticeable workmanship quality. Clients describe professional, courteous crews and a responsive, accessible project manager who maintains clear communication throughout the process. Pricing is described as competitive, with a transparent and non-pressuring sales approach, and reviewers note that the team is accommodating of scheduling needs and unique circumstances. Several customers valued guidance during quoting, noted ongoing follow-up and photos of work, and expressed willingness to hire again or recommend the company for future exterior projects, including siding. The services mentioned typically encompass roofing, gutters, soffit, fascia, and occasionally chimney inspections or related recommendations.

The reviews show a mix of very positive and negative experiences with Pro Valley Roofing (James and team). Potential customers should note both ends of the spectrum when evaluating the company for roofing, siding, or gutter work.

- Sales and pricing: Some customers praise fair pricing, clear explanations, and value (including discounts or veteran discounts). Others report aggressive or pushy sales tactics, rapid price reductions during pitches, and concerns about predatory behavior or “lip service” without follow-through.

- Scheduling and reliability: Several accounts describe missed appointments or no-shows (and in one case, a cancellation the day after agreeing to a basic cleaning). Other customers report prompt responses, same-day inspections, and timely project initiation.

- Communication and service approach: Positive experiences highlight proactive communication, regular updates, and the owner’s involvement in assessing storm damage, coordinating with insurers, and meeting with adjusters. Negative feedback mentions rude interactions, frequent calls to a manager, and poor follow-up or difficulty getting in touch.

- Work quality and process: Several reviews commend the craftsmanship, workmanship, and thorough cleanup (including leaving the yard clean and free of nails). On projects with siding, customers note good color matching and the use of high-quality materials. Some reviews emphasize transparency about potential costs and minimizing final invoice surprises.

- Overall satisfaction and referrals: A number of customers highly recommend the company, praising professionalism, fair pricing, and reliable service. However, other reviews advise caution due to inconsistent scheduling, sales pressure, and communication issues.

- Services specific: The company is described as handling roofing, siding, and gutters, with some projects featuring complete replacement, cleanups, and post-install follow-ups by James to ensure standards.

Customer experiences for Nickols Roofing and Gutters are largely positive across roofing and gutter projects, with several recurring practical themes for potential customers:

- Process and communication: Customers report clear, detailed estimates (often with photos or videos), explanations of needed work, and frequent, proactive updates throughout the project. Some noted door-to-door neighbor notices to inform others of upcoming work. Post-project follow-up and final inspections were common.

- Scheduling and responsiveness: Projects were typically scheduled promptly, with some starting sooner than expected and crew availability within about a week in at least one case. The team was described as responsive and able to adjust as needed.

- Professionalism and workmanship: The crews were characterized as hard-working, courteous, and mindful of surrounding property. Installations included roofing, gutters, fascia, and soffits, with attention to precise fit and appearance (e.g., gutters matching the trim, high-quality materials).

- Site handling and cleanup: Customers emphasized thorough cleanup, landscape protection (flowers and plants safeguarded), and careful post-work tidying. Magnet sweeps for nails and organized dumpster disposal were mentioned as part of the cleanup.

- Protection of property and neighbors: Crews minimized disruption (avoiding loud music, preserving property, and coordinating with neighbors when starting work).

- Outcomes and performance: Reported improvements included fixed leaks, absence of drips, improved gutter performance, and proper water drainage away from foundations. Some projects noted addressing issues beyond the original scope (e.g., detecting improperly installed gutters).

- Value and pricing: Several customers described the pricing as reasonable or competitive, with comments suggesting high value for the quality and scope of work.

- Personnel noted: Willie (project lead), Josh (job coordinator), and Andy Nickols (business owner) are frequently mentioned positively for communication, knowledge, integrity, and customer care.

- Recommendations: Based on multiple experiences, customers commonly stated they would highly recommend Nickols Roofing and Gutters to others.

- Range of projects: siding installation and repair, window replacement, roofing, gutters, and related exterior work on homes of various sizes (including a 3-story house and a 135-year-old home), as well as a shed and garage.
- Materials and results: work often involved vinyl siding, aluminum wrapping for doors/windows and shed, and engineered lumber for wrapping jams; several reviews describe a maintenance-free, high-quality finish and strong attention to detail.
- Speed and workmanship: many crews completed sizable projects quickly (commonly in 2 days for large homes); customers reported professional, meticulous crews and thorough cleanup; some projects noted exceptional finish and problem-solving on unexpected issues.
- Personnel and process: multiple positive mentions of sales staff (e.g., Victor, Jake, Junior, Isaac) and project managers (Ricky, Hunter, Jeremy); customers praised thorough quotes, helpful explanations, responsive communication, and use of modern tools (Hover app) to facilitate the process.
- Customer satisfaction and referrals: broad positive sentiment, with strong recommendations for siding and window projects and appreciation for friendly, knowledgeable staff; several customers highlighted that they would hire Infinity Exteriors again.
- Price and guarantees: Infinity Exteriors was competitive on bids, often beating others with similar products and offering solid guarantees; some customers used the ability to fund additional work (e.g., garage shingles) due to favorable pricing.
- Notable issues and criticisms: at least one project reported lack of on-site supervision for subcontractors, communication gaps, language barriers with subs, and several workmanship concerns (tarps ripped, nails exposed, chimney flashing issues) leading to dissatisfaction and a call for better supervision; one reviewer mentioned feeling misled about subcontractor management and proposed improvement in on-site oversight.
- Overall takeaway for potential customers: generally positive experiences with high-quality workmanship, strong customer service, and efficient project timelines; potential buyers should inquire about on-site supervision and subcontractor coordination to avoid the issues highlighted by the negative review.

Reviews show Valley Exteriors delivering siding and related exterior work with generally strong communication, responsiveness, and reasonable pricing. Positive feedback highlights prompt estimates, clean work sites, and courteous staff, with several mentioning good workmanship on siding and roofing. However, the experiences are not uniform: some customers report scheduling delays, inconsistent crews, and below-average workmanship, indicating variability in service quality.

- Overall, customer experiences are overwhelmingly positive.
- Frequent quick responses and clear, ongoing communication from Brian (manager) and guidance from Sam (owner) are highlighted.
- Services covered include roof replacement, attic ventilation fixes, siding, gutters, and sheathing replacement, as well as repairs after hail and wind damage; customers note assistance with insurance claims and coordination.
- Crews are described as courteous, efficient, and careful around landscaping, with thorough cleanup and timely completion.
- Value is emphasized: multiple customers chose Fox Valley for being competitively priced and offering good overall value relative to other quotes.
- Notable examples of strong post-service support: a fascia reinstallation at no charge after wind damage and next-day follow-up repairs; willingness to return to fix issues or address additional concerns.
- Many customers plan to use them for future projects (e.g., windows, siding) and consistently recommend the company, underscoring their long-standing presence (40+ years) and trusted reputation.

- Overall: The customer experiences with Square Oaks Home Improvements are mixed. Several customers praised professionalism, thorough installation, and high-quality workmanship, while others criticized pricing, communication, and post-installation issues.

- Positive themes:
- Thorough, detail-oriented installation and responsive, professional staff (examples mention James for the estimate, Pamela for design input, Nate for installation, Jen in the office).
- No-pressure sales approach reported by at least one reviewer.
- Windows and siding generally described as looking good and improving comfort/appearance.
- Timely completion and good follow-up in many projects.

- Price and sales concerns:
- Multiple reviews note Square Oaks was the most expensive option or quoted higher than competitors, sometimes by a large margin.
- Some reviewers felt marketing or TV ads misrepresented pricing or company capabilities, and questioned the value relative to other bids.

- Lead times and scheduling:
- Reports of long lead times between order and installation (example: order August 2024, installed February 2025).

- Installation issues and workmanship concerns:
- Water intrusion or leakage at bay windows and issues with the top aluminum cap, caulking, and drip edges.
- Trim gaps, misalignment, missing or inconsistent shims, and nail-hole filler issues on kitchen windows.
- Some installations required follow-up work, and one review cited continuing concerns about moisture/fogging and warranty handling.
- One incident described property damage (dining room flooring and siding) during installation, with later compensation.

- Warranty and post-install service:
- Several reviews mention difficulty obtaining timely responses from management (e.g., VP of sales) after issues were raised.
- Warranty promises described as complicated, with examples where only partial window replacements were performed and post-warranty service charges applied.
- Reports that the company sought additional documentation (photos) before approving replacements.

- Communication and responsiveness:
- Mixed experiences: some customers reported helpful, timely communication (office staff, project managers); others reported unreturned calls or delayed follow-up on issues.

- Neighborhood and logistics:
- Occasional complaints about work crews occupying driveways or blocking mailboxes, affecting neighbors.

- Practical takeaway for potential customers:
- Expect a high level of workmanship and professional interaction from several staffers, but be prepared for variable pricing compared with other bids.
- Confirm lead times and installation schedules in writing; ask for a detailed, written scope of work and a clear warranty explanation.
- Review past customer references and request to see completed projects similar to yours.
- Specifically discuss potential installation risks (e.g., water intrusion, trim gaps) and the plan for addressing any issues that arise post-installation.

Ridge Top Exteriors offers siding, windows, and door installations with a focus on communication and workmanship. Reviews frequently highlight responsive communication, frequent progress updates (including photos), and skilled crews delivering thorough, tidy installs. Specific staff are named positively, and projects are described as transforming exteriors, sometimes in a single visit (e.g., multiple windows and a door frame in one day). Most feedback is favorable regarding quality and customer service, with pricing often described as reasonable. There is a safety complaint about a company truck and at least one note of incomplete follow-up (caulking and leftover stain not returned after several months). No warranty details are mentioned in the reviews.

Customer reviews describe Superior Exteriors & Interiors WI as a contractor handling roofing, siding, gutters, trim, and exterior improvements, including projects with new roofs, soffits, windows, and doors, as well as permanent lighting installations. Clients commended clear communication, strong coordination across multiple trades, timely or earlier-than-expected completion, and thorough post-project cleanup. While a few reviews noted scheduling or coordination hiccups, these were typically resolved with a focus on customer satisfaction. Warranties mentioned include shingle and workmanship warranties, and pricing was generally viewed as reasonable or favorable relative to other quotes, with some reviews noting insurance-related discounts tied to roofing work.

- Services performed: siding replacement (including exterior updates), roof replacement, windows/doors, gutters, exterior insulation, and even garage additions or full home makeovers. Several projects involved multiple scopes within a single renovation.

- Quality and workmanship: consistently described as high quality with good craftsmanship and attention to detail.

- Timeliness and budgeting: many reviews report completing work in a timely manner and within quoted budgets; pricing is generally described as fair or reasonable.

- Communication and process: customers note pleasant initial contact, complete and easy-to-understand estimates, thorough explanations to prevent surprises, and ongoing responsiveness throughout the project and after completion.

- Insurance coordination: several reviews highlight proactive assistance with insurance claims and representation, with project managers helping navigate coverage and decisions.

- Project management and personnel: Jesse (owner) and Derek (project lead) are frequently cited; crews are described as professional, accommodating, and easy to work with, with good overall project guidance and input.

- Site handling and safety: crews are described as neat, orderly, and respectful of the property; special attention to safety and, in at least one case, to keeping animals safe on-site.

- After-service support: customers report helpful follow-up and availability for questions after the job ends, reinforcing long-term relationships.

- Trust and recommendations: a strong pattern of high customer satisfaction, with many customers recommending ACS and planning to use them for future projects.

- Overall sentiment: neutral-to-positive with emphasis on practical outcomes, reliable communication, and dependable workmanship.

- Dempsey Roofing (Appleton, WI) is a family-owned business operating since 1979 that focuses on roofing, siding, and home improvements with a small crew and direct on-site involvement by Kevin.
- Several customers report a one-day roof replacement at a price lower than competing bids, attributed to lower overhead and limited advertising; costs outside the bid are described as fairly priced and discussed upfront.
- Jobs often included careful protection of landscaping and outdoor spaces (flower beds, back deck) and thorough cleanup, with claims that crews worked past typical hours to complete the job in one day.
- The company reportedly handled unexpected issues (e.g., two layers of shingles, decking rot) and offered repairs at fair value to ensure proper results.
- Attic heat problems were addressed by adding six box vents to improve ventilation, with noted improvements in temperature and second-floor comfort; adjustments were made to balance costs and project specifics (no soffits in the home).
- Kevin is typically the point of contact who explains work upfront and uses documentation (photos) to show damages and planned repairs; customers report transparent communication and fair pricing for extra work.
- Overall sentiment among many reviews is positive, highlighting workmanship, professional cleanup, and reliability, with several reviewers stating they would hire again and would recommend Dempsey Roofing.
- There is at least one negative review alleging a contract issue and advising others not to hire, and another remark suggesting a misalignment between a rubber roof installation and subsequent costs; this indicates some dissatisfaction among a portion of customers.

- Overall impression: Customers report generally positive experiences with Security-Luebke Roofing/Security Luebke, especially for roofing, gutters, siding, and insulation work. Many reviews highlight high-quality workmanship, professional crews, thorough cleanup, and a one-stop approach to complete exterior projects.

- What customers commonly praised: thorough explanations of materials and installation, punctual scheduling, reliable communication during the project, and clear, detailed proposals. Several projects involved multiple components (roof, gutters, insulation, siding) completed in a single, cohesive effort. Cleanups were reported to be very thorough, leaving little to no debris behind. Several reviewers also noted friendly, helpful staff and strong attention to detail.

- Notable positive outcomes: projects completed on time or as scheduled, proper repairs rather than quick fixes in some cases, and durable results (e.g., gutters functioning well after rain, new siding/stone looking good). Multiple customers expressed high satisfaction and would consider using them again or recommending them.

- Mixed or negative experiences to watch for: a few customers reported poor communication from the office or during the project, including schedule changes not being relayed and delays. One customer described being ignored after an issue and incurring a separate repair cost, indicating potential post-project responsiveness issues. A couple of reviews mentioned higher-than-expected costs.

- Practical takeaways for potential customers: expect a comprehensive exterior project with options for roofing, gutters, siding, gutters toppers, insulation, or stone; request a single, integrated plan and written timeline; confirm who will handle post-install service and warranty details; clarify costs up front and what is included in the price; maintain written contact points and follow up on any schedule changes to avoid miscommunication.

- Overall sentiment: many customers view the company as a top choice in the Fox Valley area for roofing and related exterior work, with strong praise for quality and service, but with caution advised regarding communication and after-service responsiveness.

Customer reviews consistently describe Empire Exteriors as professional and reliable, with emphasis on responsive communication, efficient crews, and thorough cleanup. Reviewers praised hospitality, knowledge, and timely coordination with insurance, and noted that crews were fast, cleanup was thorough, and scheduling was reliable. No reviews mentioned specific siding materials, warranties, or pricing details.

Two customers provided positive feedback. The first said the crew was focused once work began, completed roof work several months ago, and the result looks amazing with no current problems. The second described a punctual, kind worker who communicated well and finished the project, and they recommended the company for roofing needs.

Pachner Exteriors appears to handle roofing, gutters, and fascia work, including hail-damage repair and insurance claim assistance. Reviews include many positive notes about professionalism, thorough documentation, fast quoting, good cleanup, and on-time completion at reasonable cost, with customers willing to recommend them. However, there are notable negatives: several reports of poor communication and long delays in obtaining invoices, and some cases of questionable workmanship (bulges in shingles, damaged fascia, leaks) or unfinished issues with debris left on the property. Overall, the service is described as capable with strong customer interaction in many instances, but with inconsistent communication and mixed workmanship outcomes in others.

Customer reviews for Kingdom Roofing (siding, roofing, and gutters) are largely positive and consistently highlight practical, job-focused aspects useful to potential buyers. Key patterns include:

- Quoting and communication: Professional, thorough estimates with straightforward pricing; proactive, responsive communication (often centered on Adam as the primary contact). Many customers cited help with insurance processes and color selection.
- Scheduling and speed: On-site crews arriving on time and completing work efficiently; several projects completed in a single day (including tear-offs and roof installations on multi-story homes).
- Work quality and site handling: Hard-working crews that protect landscaping, manage tight spaces, and minimize disruption to neighbors; careful demolition and installation; notable attention to cleanup, nail removal, and post-work checks.
- Project scope and results: Work across roofing, siding, gutters, and leaf filters; improvements such as attic ventilation considered; high customer satisfaction with the finished results and long-term durability.
- Project management: Strong coordination of materials to prevent yard clutter; clear updates during the project; willingness to adjust to weather and scheduling constraints.
- Value and referrals: Perceived reasonable pricing and good value; multiple customers stated they would recommend Kingdom Roofing and would reuse them for future needs.

In sum, customers report reliable service, strong communication, efficient execution, careful site management, and satisfactory, long-lasting results across roofing, siding, and gutter projects.

Overall, customers report positive, informative experiences with a no-pressure sales approach and clear explanations throughout the process.

Key representatives frequently mentioned:
- Chris Kliner (Chris K): praised for professionalism, thorough explanations, demonstrations, and helpful product options.
- Dean: described as knowledgeable and easy to work with.
- Jack: noted for thoroughness and answering questions.

Sales process and practical details:
- On-site demonstrations and product presentations with multiple options.
- Quotes provided; many customers found options within their price range.
- In several cases, contracts were signed the same day, sometimes with an extra discount arranged by a manager.

Product focus and outcomes:
- Projects include siding and windows, with some references to doors; products described as sturdy.
- Several customers highlighted successful problem-solving (e.g., a custom front entry door with sidelights).
- Customers feel informed and comfortable proceeding, with installation anticipated afterward.