Top Siding Repair Services in Lancaster

Smucker Exteriors & Remodeling specializes in exterior home renovations including siding replacement (notably Hardie plank fiber cement siding) and vinyl siding, window and door installations, exterior trim, and deck rebuilds. Reviews consistently describe courteous, professional crews with strong communication and attention to detail, delivering projects from siding-only to multi-material exterior makeovers. Timelines cited include decks rebuilt in under two weeks and a garage project completed in about four days, with many jobs spanning several weeks. While overall praised for quality and service, some customers note higher pricing compared to competitors and have expressed concerns about the initial estimate process. Overall, customers report high satisfaction and a willingness to reuse or recommend Smucker Exteriors.

- The Exterior Company (TEC) handles roofing, gutters, downspouts, and siding, with project managers including Zach Fawber, Josh Jenkins, Daryl Brubaker, Aaron Sullivan, Jim Kerr, Cody Cappon, and others who are repeatedly praised for guidance through insurance claims and product selections.
- Many customers report strong, prompt communication and a clear process from start to finish, though a few note delays, crews disappearing for days, or inconsistent updates during the siding project.
- TEC is often described as supportive with insurance claims, with project managers meeting adjusters and guiding customers through the process; a few customers experienced disagreements over scope or costs.
- Work quality and outcomes are generally positive for roofing and gutters, with several projects described as thorough and professional; some customers report issues with siding, such as damage, delays, and incomplete work, and a few concerns about leaks or improper installations.
- Cleanup and site condition are frequently praised, but there are instances of negative experiences, including garbage left behind, nails on the ground, or disruptive worksite practices.
- Timelines vary: many projects are completed efficiently, while siding jobs are cited by some as lengthy and troublesome.
- Pricing experiences range from reasonable out-of-pocket costs and deductible handling to at least one report of a large unanticipated charge after completion for materials.
- Overall sentiment is mixed but leans positive when projects go as planned and communication is strong; several testimonials specifically commend individual project managers, while a minority recount frustrating, costly, or poorly coordinated experiences.
- Potential customers should expect dedicated project management, proactive insurance claim support, and transparent communication, but should also verify scope, timelines, cleanup responsibilities, and any potential post-completion charges, especially for siding work.

Graystone Roofing & Siding (Brian Spicher) is consistently described as responsive, professional, and skilled in exterior projects, with most customers reporting high satisfaction and clear advice throughout the process.

- Project scope and outcomes: Roofing, siding, gutters, and window-related work are common. Projects included wind, hail, or storm-damage replacements, siding updates on aging homes, and new construction windows and doors. Notable details mentioned include a CertainTeed Landmark roof system and a slate roof replacement on a carriage house, with several customers noting color matching and overall aesthetic improvements.

- Estimating and pricing: Many reviewers emphasized prompt, competitive, and fair pricing with no hidden fees. Several quotes were compared, and Graystone’s bid was frequently cited as competitive or best in value.

- Scheduling and timelines: Work is described as timely, with instances of rapid completion (for example, roofs finished in one to two days). Customers often noted timely responses and adherence to planned timelines.

- Quality and workmanship: Reputable workmanship is repeatedly highlighted, including precise installations, attention to detail, and work that matches or exceeds expectations. Several customers remarked that crews treated their homes with care and maintained clean job sites.

- Customer service and communication: The team is frequently praised for responsiveness, clear communication, and willingness to address questions and adjustments during the project. Staff were described as courteous, professional, and easy to work with.

- Cleanup and site management: Cleanups after installations are commonly singled out as thorough and well-handled, leaving the property tidy at project completion.

- Overall sentiment and recommendations: Across reviews, customers express strong satisfaction, willingness to recommend Graystone, and in many cases, a desire to reuse the contractor for future exterior needs. Some customers describe the experience as low-stress and straightforward, with one noting the contractor’s honesty and fairness.

- The experiences are mixed: several customers report highly positive outcomes, while at least one review describes a negative sales experience.
- Services mentioned include window replacements, patio/sliding doors, back doors, front doors, storm doors, and a roof replacement in one case.
- Installation quality is frequently praised: workers are described as courteous, detail-oriented, quick and precise, with examples of one installer handling multiple windows and others completing jobs efficiently.
- Product results are noted as aesthetically pleasing and functional, with improvements such as clearer windows and improved moisture-related issues.
- Customer service and communication are cited positively in many reviews, including thorough answers to questions and helpful staff throughout the process; some praise also extended to post-installation check-ins.
- A negative review highlights high-pressure sales tactics, a lack of follow-up on a promised written quote, and overall unprofessional/unethical impressions.
- A few testimonials emphasize a dog-friendly, welcoming experience from staff.
- Practical takeaways for potential customers: Aspen appears capable of handling multiple home-improvement projects (windows, doors, and roofing); expect generally strong workmanship and service, but be aware of potential pressure to purchase amid sales discussions and ensure you obtain and review written quotes.

Customer experiences with Smucker & Sons are overwhelmingly positive across multiple projects over several years. Clients consistently cite responsive communication, professional conduct, and fair pricing as factors that influenced their decision to hire them, followed by prompt scheduling and thorough installation. Reported projects include windows and siding replacement, roof completion, front door installations, sunroom additions, and deck work, with several customers noting improvements in curb appeal and home comfort.

Common practical details:
- Services: windows and doors replacement, siding, roofing, sunrooms, and decks; some projects included dining room renovations.
- Process and service: low-pressure sales approach, clear explanations, upfront expectations, and detailed measurements coordinated by office staff; daily on-site communication and end-of-day cleanup are frequently mentioned.
- Quality and workmanship: high craftsmanship, precise, durable results; attention to detail and pride in work; installers are described as courteous and professional.
- Timelines and budget: many reviews indicate projects stayed on schedule and within budget.
- Team and reliability: multiple installers are repeatedly praised (e.g., Ed, Manny, Justin, Lamar, Luke, Phil, Jack B, April); customers note trustworthy, friendly staff and thorough problem resolution.
- Outcomes: repeat customers and recommendations are common; several comments reference warranties on products and long-lasting results.
- Neighborhood: reviews identify Lancaster County as the service area and express willingness to hire again for future projects.

Summary of customer experiences with Premier Siding and Roofing:

Customers reported hail damage to roofs and siding and used Premier to assess and document the damage. Pete Welsh (and sometimes Gee) conducted on-site inspections, took photos for insurance, and often advised requesting a second insurer inspection, which Pete would attend. In many cases the insurer acknowledged substantial damage after the second inspection, and Premier proceeded with roof and siding replacement, sometimes including gutters and downspouts. Customers generally described the work as completed on time and as promised, with thorough cleanup and professional, responsive communication from Pete and the crew. Several testimonials highlighted Pete’s advocacy with the insurance company, his quick responses, and the overall quality and appearance of the finished work. Word-of-mouth referrals appeared in multiple accounts, with neighbors noting the improvements and some following Premier’s lead for their own repairs. While one customer noted an initial claim denial with a different company, Premier’s involvement was described as helpful in securing a favorable outcome. Overall, feedback was strongly positive and many customers would highly recommend Premier Siding and Roofing for roof and siding replacements related to hail damage.

Overall, customers report positive experiences with Abel & Son Roofing, noting professional service, clear communication, strong workmanship, and thorough cleanup across roof replacements and related work (gutters, windows, deck doors).

- Services and scope: Primarily roof replacement, with additional work on gutters, windows, deck doors, and occasional siding; in one case a roof repair plus shingle installation was quoted and completed.
- Communication and estimations: Estimates are described as clear and thorough, with explanations of options; the team (especially Sean) is highlighted for responsiveness, transparency, and help throughout the process.
- Pricing and value: Several reviews describe competitive pricing and obtaining favorable quotes; some mention cost increases but with clear explanations and continued value.
- Scheduling and timeline: Jobs are often completed in a few days; crews are reported as punctual and able to start earlier than planned when possible; weather can extend timelines, but crews adapt and communicate changes.
- Quality and cleanup: High quality workmanship with attention to detail; experienced crews; extensive cleanup, including nail removal and debris cleanup, with care taken to protect the home during work.
- Crew professionalism and trust: Foremen and crews are professional and courteous; involvement from owners and family is noted as a positive aspect; staff are described as polite, knowledgeable, and patient in explaining processes.
- Aftercare and problem resolution: Prompt follow-up on issues (e.g., leaks around chimneys) and willingness to address additional needs; some reviews mention post-install checks and photos to verify work.
- Overall sentiment: Repeatedly described as a reliable, value-driven choice for roofing and related exterior work, with many customers stating they would recommend Abel & Son to others.

- Reviews consistently describe Kings Extreme Exteriors as on-time, courteous, and professional, with clear and thorough communication from Lee and Steve.
- Work quality is repeatedly praised as high with strong attention to detail; projects are described as well-crafted results and, in some cases, “showpiece” outcomes.
- The company handles a broad range of exterior projects, including decks (replacement and additions), roofing with dormers, siding, windows, decorative features, exterior makeovers, and barn exteriors.
- Projects are noted for efficient execution and organized crews; daily cleanup is common, with many customers able to use outdoor spaces soon after work begins; some projects were completed quickly even in winter.
- Pricing is regarded as fair and competitive; several customers reported bids much lower than competitors and appreciated honest pricing without gouging; upgrades or value-added improvements were sometimes included at no extra charge.
- Customers report collaborative experiences, with the team accommodating ideas, offering thorough explanations, and keeping clients informed throughout the process.
- Repeat business and referrals are common themes, with many customers indicating they would recommend Kings Extreme Exteriors to family and friends.
- Specific technical practices mentioned include not burying posts and using 12-inch joist centers on decks; some descriptions note use of a “showroom on wheels” to illustrate options.

The reviews are overwhelmingly positive for Armor Roofing (a roofing contractor). They describe high-quality workmanship, professional and courteous service, responsive communication, and thorough site cleanup. Several reviews note on-time or early completion and fair pricing. A few mentions describe handling unexpected scheduling changes smoothly and addressing minor issues promptly (e.g., nail pops, patching, repaint). There are no explicit references to siding repairs, warranties, or maintenance programs in these reviews; some advice is given on evaluating moisture issues and potential do-it-yourself steps. Overall, customers report strong workmanship and reliable service, with the caveat that this collection focuses on roofing projects.

Zephyr-Thomas (ZT) has a strong track record of positive customer experiences across a range of home-improvement projects over many years, including siding, porches, windows, doors, and interior updates. Reported strengths include: a broad selection of high-quality materials with a patient, non-pushy approach; professional workmanship that handles unexpected site issues and delivers precise results (for example, show-and-tell demonstrations of custom bends and exact window fits); thorough cleanup and minimization of dust; and clear communication with customers, with sales staff (notably Josh) and crew leads providing timely updates and explanations.

Projects cited have commonly involved detailed, multi-phase work such as replacing or upgrading exterior features (siding on eaves, porch railing, storm doors, gutters, outdoor lighting, fencing, shutters) and interior improvements (windows, doors, bathroom and kitchen updates, laundry/mud-room additions, and even sunroom or screened-porch expansions). Several testimonials highlight the ability to complete work efficiently and to schedule commitments and follow through on promises, often with multiple projects completed for the same customers.

A recurring theme is customer satisfaction from repeat clients, with several reviews noting long-standing relationships (up to 15 years) and high levels of trust and referrals. Customers frequently commend the craftsmanship, responsiveness, professionalism, and respect for the home and property, including stopping by to confirm satisfaction and providing plans or explanations of work.

There is at least one negative experience noted: a reviewer described a crew member’s rude response when asked about pricing and services, and perceived discriminatory vibes, raising concerns about professionalism in that instance. Overall, most feedback emphasizes positive outcomes, but this isolated incident suggests that consistent respectful interaction is important for potential customers to consider.

In summary, customers generally report reliable, skilled workmanship, good communication, and respectful handling of a variety of home-improvement projects, with multiple long-term and repeat engagements, while noting one adverse interaction as a cautionary example.

Creek Hill Renovations, led by Ike Esh, handles a range of home projects including siding work, porch woodwork, and deck installations. Reviews consistently highlight high-quality materials (notably cedar for woodwork), on-time scheduling, thorough planning and walkthroughs, and strong craftsmanship. Customers express satisfaction with communication, flexibility to accommodate changes, and plans to reuse the company for future renovations.

- Overall workmanship: Professional, quiet, and neat performance reported by neighbors; craftsmen described as professional and respectful.

- Specific outcomes: Copper cupola and brass eagle weathervane placed properly after being stored in a garage for three years.

- Inspection and pricing: Mr. King performed a thorough inspection, provided what customers described as the best price, and the team completed the work in about two days. A refund was issued for unused drain and gutter materials; honesty and doing the right thing were highlighted.

- Window replacement: Windows replaced with professional service from start to finish; quality product, evident craftsmanship, cleanliness, and attention to small details; highly recommended.

- Timeline and cost: Work noted as timely and responsive; completed for significantly less than competing estimates.

- Roofing service and customer support: Jason responded quickly to assess and repair issues; reliable for urgent roof repairs; customers would call again and highly recommend for strong customer service.

Zimmerman Exteriors is described as a professional and courteous contractor handling roofing, siding repairs, and related work (including gutters and storm damage). Reviews frequently commend quality workmanship, attention to detail, and good communication, with examples of complex projects on historic homes. Some customers note prompt, same-day responses for emergencies and assistance with insurance claims, while a minority report slower follow-up or not receiving a requested estimate. Overall, the feedback suggests high-quality results and good value for exterior repairs, though occasional communication gaps are noted.

Customer reviews consistently praise Golden Exteriors for exterior work including siding and window frame repairs, with roofing mentioned in multiple cases. The team is described as very responsive, professional, thorough, and communicative, often completing work quickly and leaving clean results. EIFS (Exterior Insulation and Finish System) is specifically highlighted as a material finish. Pricing is generally viewed as fair, and several reviewers note good value for money. The company appears to offer a guarantee on diagnoses with free follow-up repairs if needed, and several customers commend their assistance with insurance coordination. No significant negatives are reported in the reviews.

Reviews consistently describe Helm Construction as responsive and communicative from the initial quote through project completion. Customers report quick assessment of post-installation issues, rapid scheduling (often within a few days), and clear updates during the work. Crews are praised for thorough daily cleanup, professionalism, and efficiency; foreman Leon is frequently highlighted for leadership and customer-focused communication. Pricing is described as fair and reasonable, with multiple reviewers noting they shopped around and still chose Helm for value. Projects range from roofing and gutters replaced in a single day to large roofs (e.g., about 5,000 sq ft) completed in two days; in some cases a second neighboring roof was handled the same day. The company is commended for assisting with insurance coordination, providing progress photos, and ensuring follow-up. Office staff Cory and Alex are cited as helpful in estimates and scheduling. Overall sentiment is very positive, with many customers indicating they would hire Helm again and recommend them, and only a few mentions of delays attributed to weather or scheduling constraints.

Grove & Son (George J. Grove & Son, Inc.) is described by customers as a locally owned exterior home remodeler specializing in window replacement, siding, doors, gutters, roofing, and related work. Installations were performed by consistent crews that often included Chris, John, Josh, and Roger, with other team members such as Thomas, Zach, Jason, Brady, Lloyd, Nathan, Terry, and Jon mentioned across reviews. Customers report on-time arrival, professional and courteous service, careful handling of homes, and thorough cleanup after completion. Projects ranged from replacing a few windows to large jobs (e.g., 9–17 windows, plus exterior doors), with many installations completed in a single day and some multi-person crews working 8+ hours to finish. Quotes were typically provided on-site, with a remeasure in some cases; weather and scheduling delays were noted as occasional factors. Overall, customers express high satisfaction and would recommend the company and hire them again for similar work.

Customer feedback for Sunnyside Roofing (and related Mark’s team) describes consistently positive experiences with roofing and exterior work. Key practical details include:

- Services performed: metal roof installation; roof with dormers; window addition and replacements; broader exterior work.
- Crew and conduct: professional, friendly, and personally attentive to the home; came early, worked hard, and left sites tidy.
- Communication and documentation: estimators and crews (Melvin, Isaac, Gideon, Danny) were responsive, knowledgeable, and kept lines of communication open; estimates were followed without deviation.
- Quality and finish: high-quality products and workmanship; end results described as remarkable with good fit and finish.
- Timeliness and safety: projects completed in a timely manner; crews were careful and safe on the job.
- Value and materials: perceived affordable pricing; some comments noting the use of local products and good value.
- Customer sentiment: customers would recommend Sunnyside and would consider using them again for future exterior work; many described feeling well treated and valued as customers.

Overall, customers report prompt response, clear communication, and reliable, high-quality work across roofing and siding repairs. Specific recurring themes include:
- Quick response and scheduling, often arriving next day or completing repairs the same day.
- Thorough diagnostics, with explanations often supplemented by photos and a clear, stable estimate.
- A wide range of services handled, including fixing leaks, replacing shingles, chimney flashing, skylight issues, siding and trim work, gutters and leaf-guard concerns, and roof inspections.
- Fair, predictable pricing with estimates that do not deviate, and customers noting good value and budget-friendly options.
- Honest assessments and professional guidance, including advice on insurance possibilities; several customers had insurers approve full roof replacements after recommendations.
- Quality results that hold up to weather tests, with reports of dry attics and leaks resolved.
- Professionalism and reliability, including punctuality, courteous service, regular updates, and leaving the site cleaner than found.
- Positive customer loyalty and recommendations, with several customers stating they would hire again and would refer others.

- Services provided: siding repair/replacement, exterior remodeling, window and door replacements, fascia work, gutters and gutter protection, roofing (including standing seam), shutters, and related exterior improvements; also did a home addition project.

- Typical project pace: several reviews note quick, efficient work (e.g., 10 windows replaced in a week; projects completed on time and as promised).

- Quality and workmanship: many customers describe high-quality results, friendly and professional crews, careful handling of homes, and attention to detail.

- Communication and planning: several reviews highlight thorough planning and regular updates during projects; a few cite strong, clear communication from sales staff (Joel, Phil) and installers (Shawn, Mike). A few negative experiences mention poor communication or responsiveness from a specific representative.

- Pricing and value: common sentiment is fair or competitive pricing, with some noting lower costs than competitors; a minority report higher or delayed estimates and billing concerns.

- Staffing and reliability: reviewers frequently emphasize that Eby is a small local company with in-house full-time installers and direct points of contact; many would use them again (including for future barn roof work).

- Problem solving and responsiveness: in cases where issues were found (e.g., wood rot and pest activity), crews addressed them professionally; one reviewer praised flexible scheduling to accommodate an urgent vine-removal request.

- Notable positives: strong endorsements for Marvin windows, quick multi-window replacement, thorough exterior work (including siding, trim, gutters, and gutter protection), and favorable customer service from leadership and installers.

- Notable cautions: at least two reviews describe negative experiences with a sales representative and a lack of follow-up on estimates, including missed roofing estimate callbacks and a no-show for an appointment. Potential customers may want to confirm communication expectations and follow through before scheduling.

- Overall sentiment: broadly positive, with many satisfied customers and multiple 5-star style endorsements; a minority highlight reliability and communication gaps.

Customer feedback portrays Zimmerman's Roofing as generally positive in both office and on-site interactions, with clear communication, professionalism, and thorough inspections across multiple services. Key practical details include:

- Cody Benjamin: provided thorough leak-preparation estimates (often about two hours on-site), explained what work is needed, and outlined the no-leak warranty; communicates clearly and is seen as knowledgeable. Initial estimates were described as non-pushy with multiple pricing options and competitive pricing.

- Fabian: conducted roof check-ups in a professional, pleasant manner; addressed issues promptly, including sealing a gap after noting buckled ridge-cap shingles, with assistance from another technician (Matt) as needed.

- Matthew: arrived on time with an assistant for window shutter work, consulted to ensure work matched the customer’s preferences, completed tasks efficiently, and also checked gutters; noted for helpful, service-with-a-smile demeanor and thorough explanations.

- General service: customers repeatedly described excellent staff demeanor, punctuality, and helpfulness; the company’s communication included text alerts about arrival and detailed explanations of findings and options.

- Siding replacement concern: one customer reported that after vinyl siding replacement, pieces blew off during storms, and there was no evidence that proper fasteners were used to secure the siding, suggesting potential installation quality issues.

- Overall sentiment: customers would recommend Zimmerman's Roofing to family and friends, and many would hire them again, citing thorough inspections, clear explanations, and attentive service.