
Smucker Exteriors & Remodeling LLC
263 Hershey Church Rd, Kinzers, PA 17535, USA
- Services provided: siding repair/replacement, exterior remodeling, window and door replacements, fascia work, gutters and gutter protection, roofing (including standing seam), shutters, and related exterior improvements; also did a home addition project.
- Typical project pace: several reviews note quick, efficient work (e.g., 10 windows replaced in a week; projects completed on time and as promised).
- Quality and workmanship: many customers describe high-quality results, friendly and professional crews, careful handling of homes, and attention to detail.
- Communication and planning: several reviews highlight thorough planning and regular updates during projects; a few cite strong, clear communication from sales staff (Joel, Phil) and installers (Shawn, Mike). A few negative experiences mention poor communication or responsiveness from a specific representative.
- Pricing and value: common sentiment is fair or competitive pricing, with some noting lower costs than competitors; a minority report higher or delayed estimates and billing concerns.
- Staffing and reliability: reviewers frequently emphasize that Eby is a small local company with in-house full-time installers and direct points of contact; many would use them again (including for future barn roof work).
- Problem solving and responsiveness: in cases where issues were found (e.g., wood rot and pest activity), crews addressed them professionally; one reviewer praised flexible scheduling to accommodate an urgent vine-removal request.
- Notable positives: strong endorsements for Marvin windows, quick multi-window replacement, thorough exterior work (including siding, trim, gutters, and gutter protection), and favorable customer service from leadership and installers.
- Notable cautions: at least two reviews describe negative experiences with a sales representative and a lack of follow-up on estimates, including missed roofing estimate callbacks and a no-show for an appointment. Potential customers may want to confirm communication expectations and follow through before scheduling.
- Overall sentiment: broadly positive, with many satisfied customers and multiple 5-star style endorsements; a minority highlight reliability and communication gaps.
Stone (New Holland Stone)
Excellent
Varied; some reviews mention next-day responses or quick on-site work, while others report slow or no response for estimates.
Poor communication or failing to follow up on estimates,Missing appointments or not showing up for estimates,Pushy or unprofessional sales attitude
None mentioned
Excellent
Pricing generally fair and competitive with good value; some concerns about high labor estimates or quotes
No maintenance tips mentioned
263 Hershey Church Rd, Kinzers, PA 17535, USA
311 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603, USA
2579 Graystone Rd, East Petersburg, PA 17520, USA